Evidence and the Big Easy II

The City of New Orleans is attributed a unique place in the Kennedy assassination case with divergent historical claims resting amid the city's swirling convoluted history. New Orleans was the site of CIA activities, housed FBI offices, their network of informants, was part of Mafia boss Carlos Marcello's territory, and within this menagerie of schemes rests the city's most historically accused former citizen, Lee Harvey Oswald. It housed various federal, state, and local offices that had many connections to locally operating Cuban exiles and one of multiple exile groups funded tens of thousands of dollars monthly by the CIA was the Directorio Revolucionario Estudiantil (DRE). Such organizations had dozens of members that performed covert and often illegal programs nationally to influence public support of displacing the Cuban dictator Fidel Castro. Unimportant people with questionable motivations such as Jack Martin and David Lewis were among the denizens that often would have faded into history until they attempted to build unproven assertions concerning prior groups and the Kennedy case. These assertions and myths would offer cover to later unproven ideas for some who did not seek to reveal evidence but evolving stories that mislead the public.

Just days following President Kennedy's assassination Jack Martin launched a series of accusations toward Garrison suspect David Ferrie via written assertions labeled "important facts" in a letter to Special Agent Richard E. Robey of the Federal Aviation Agency. He correctly remembered Oswald in a Civil Air Patrol squadron that Ferrie participated in, and recalls seeing a photograph of Oswald and Ferrie but he further asserts "Ferrie was getting mail from those Cuban people Oswald was connected with...at least this is what W. Hardy Davis tell me." Martin's claims reside on secondhand information and rumor without offering a bit of proof to support his most unlikely ideas.

Jack Martin made several unproven assertions regarding David Ferrie

Jack Martin made several unproven assertions regarding David Ferrie

"We might also take into consideration that Ferrie was a professional hypnotist...that he used post hypnotic suggestion on his so-called candidates...when he advertised himself as "Ph.D." Martin's implication was that Ferrie somehow hypnotized Oswald to undertake the plot. Indeed Ferrie had misrepresented alleged credentials; his "doctoral degree" emerged from an unaccredited correspondence school in Europe. Similar to those who believe in the limitless power of hypnosis Martin overestimates his ability to judge something without substantial facts. While David Ferrie is a despicable person without notable merit the reasoning used by Martin had repeatedly misrepresents Ferrie's abilities because of his attempt to demonize his former ally.i ii    

Martin continues asserting, "Was not this the person (Oswald) that Ferrie helped to get in the Marine Corps...Ferrie's connection with the Cubans...Suffice it to say I am also told Ferrie had been in and out of town on several occasions just prior to this Kennedy business...Where was he..." David Ferrie was in New Orleans with Mafia leader Carlos Marcello's legal defense team. This is according to a statement voluntarily given November 25, 1963 to New Orleans Police. Ferrie offered a "detailed account" of his location prior and on November 22, 1963.iii Officials state having investigated and verified Ferrie's location in multiple instances in addition to another subsequent improbable claim attributed to Jack Martin that David Ferrie's library card was in Lee Harvey Oswald's possession. Some declare the card was a definitive link between Oswald and Ferrie and assert they were in possession of the card or destroyed it but evidence supports none of these later evolving claims.

The Federal Bureau of Investigation visited David Ferrie November 27, 1963. The Bureau's agents questioned Ferrie on his public criticisms of President Kennedy, including that he may have off-handedly commented Kennedy should be "shot". Ferrie also prior commented the President should not travel in an open car to prevent others from shooting him. Ferrie stated "he had never loaned his library card to Lee Harvey Oswald or any other person at any time and that his library card to the best of his recollection had not been out of his possession since it was issued to him." Ferrie presented his library card for verification to FBI Agents Wall and Viater and eventually Jack Martin informed authorities "he had no specific information to support his allegations."iv v Officials determined after investigation Martin allegedly impersonated an FBI Special Agent and spent time in a psychiatric ward because Martin suffered from a character disorder and was advised not meet with investigating agents due to possible worsening of his mental health.vi Official review supports Jack Martin's likely motivation for the many unlikely claims was a prior grudge against David Ferrie but Ferrie was just Martin's first purported antagonist related to the New Orleans review of President Kennedy's assassination.

Former AIRLINE Pilot and Anti-Castro Exile advocate David Ferrie

Former AIRLINE Pilot and Anti-Castro Exile advocate David Ferrie

January 13, 1967 Jack Martin informed the Bureau's New Orleans office to inform them Jim Garrison "was conducting an investigation concerning the Lee Harvey Oswald case." Weeks later Martin called the FBI again demanding, "...that the FBI stop the New Orleans District Attorney's Office from 'harassing him'." Martin's speculative ire had feasibly shifted to a new target with several unproven claims attacking his latest target's character. Martin's ideas still poison various connections related to matter some believe are important but evidence supports are largely unreliable.          

Additionally noted by officials were the unlikely stories involving Martin's former roommate David Lewis. Jack Martin claimed that Lewis was acquainted with Lee Harvey Oswald who plotted the President's death with David Ferrie.  Martin further "Alleged that this conspiracy originated in the rooms above the offices of Mr. Guy Banister in New Orleans, Louisiana."vii This document predates the Clay Shaw trial by years and is just months after Garrison had begun quietly building his case and unfortunately, some of Jack Martin's unproven allegations became part of Garrison's case. Martin was just one of many unverified sources attempting to influence the Garrison investigation and others use these poorly contrived attempting to present them as "new" insights but they remain unconvincing if facts are consulted.viii

David Lewis was interviewed by the New Orleans District Attorney's office and he told Jim Garrison "...that he had met Lee Harvey Oswald in the office of Mr. Banister." Lewis similar to some offering improbable stories claimed, "...his life is in jeopardy" due to the information he shared with the District Attorney Garrison's office. This often-repeated allegation too relies upon no verifiable evidence and unknown to Lewis prior official inquiries were inspecting his unproven claims with more verifiable sources.ix It appears the declarations of Lewis similar to those of his advocate Martin were unreliable speculation at best.  

Garrison Witness David Lewis made several claims

Garrison Witness David Lewis made several claims

Mr. George Clark Johnston the former roommate of David Lewis sent a letter to the Federal Bureau of Investigation after observing ideas given by Lewis to the media. Johnston lived with Lewis during the period of President Kennedy's assassination and subsequently observed a television show with Lewis "making numerous comments concerning the assassination..." that prompted him to contact officials. He lived "...with David Lewis in Apartment C, 1047 Conti Street, New Orleans, Louisiana, at the time of the assassination of the late President Kennedy and Johnston added that at the time he was a close confidant of Lewis. According to Johnston, at no time during the period of the assassination did Lewis ever indicate to Johnston that he had any knowledge of the assassination of President Kennedy." Quite telling is no mention of a connection until David Lewis and Jack Martin presume to benefit from the allusions with financial rewards or by defaming an enemy.

Bob Guzman a former private investigator in Guy Banister's office informed the Bureau he too was "acquainted with David Lewis". Guzman described him as the "protégé of Jack Martin" and that Martin had promoted Lewis for Banister's use yet Guzman characterized David Lewis as "uneducated and completely incompetent." Guzman states Lewis was "detective-happy" and recalled one occasion when Lewis spent most of his paycheck on a new shoulder holster, "According to Mr. Guzman, Lewis then purchased a plastic pistol" from a local department store and brandished "the holster and plastic gun around town." A confidential Bureau source of prior reliable information offered, "David Lewis is attempting in every way possible to make money out of his role in Garrison's investigation and is trying without success to sell his story to various news media for $1,000. Our source stated that he thinks Lewis should be locked up inasmuch he appears to be a dangerous mental case." Lewis received significant media publicity for his claims and likely inspired other feasible myths to emerge as well.

Seemingly, the accusations offered by Jack Martin and David Lewis had little fact and less substance that some prior declared with abandon. The unproven claims of Martin and Lewis have misled people and others have adopted them to support improbable stories. Primary evidence displays the feeble nature of the assertions and substantial verifiable problems reduce these mere rumors to proper form. They like some official and independent beliefs rely upon desire and not the strength of verifiable facts.   
C.A.A. Savastano
TPAAK Facebook

i. House Select Committee on Assassinations, Segregated Central Intelligence Agency files, Folder D, Garrison-DRE, Garrison Investigation Volume II, November 25, 1963, National Archives and Records Administration Identification Number: 1994.05.06.08:44:58:780005
ii. HSCA Report, Appendix X, Section XII, David Ferrie, p. 106
iii. HSCA Report, David Ferrie, p. 105
iv. Ibid, pp. 105-106
v. Federal Bureau of Investigation, Shaw/Allen FOIA cases, David William Ferrie-New Orleans Field Office, part 1, November 27, 1963 pp. 1-2
vi. HSCA, Segregated CIA files, Microfilm Reel 25, Folder D- Garrison Investigation Vol. II, February 21, 1967  
vii. Ibid

viii. Ibid
ix. Ibid

Edited: January 2019

Related Articles and Evidence
Evidence and the Big Easy
Evidence and the Big Easy III
Related Podcasts
The Garrison Investigation: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
JFK 101 Part 6
JFK 101 Part 7